Harry Potter Fanfic Rights Auctioned Off For $2.5M

A beloved Harry Potter fan fiction is on the verge of becoming the next major publishing event, as rights negotiations for “All the Young Dudes” reportedly center on a figure of £2.5 million. Reports circulating this week have been divided: one account suggests the auction reached that amount, while another claims a £2.5 million pre-emptive offer was declined.

The work, penned by the author known as MsKingBean89, has built an extraordinary following since its publication on Archive of Our Own between March 2017 and November 2018. Spanning 188 chapters and more than two decades of the Wizarding World’s timeline, the story has accumulated close to 20 million reads on the platform, earning the top spot on AO3’s “Top of All Fics” list.

Unlike the canonical Harry Potter series, the story centers on Remus Lupin rather than the Boy Who Lived. Beginning in the early 1970s, it traces Lupin’s life from his childhood encounter with the werewolf Fenrir Greyback, through his years at Hogwarts alongside James Potter, Sirius Black, and Peter Pettigrew, and into the early days of the Order of the Phoenix.

At its core is a love story between Lupin and Sirius Black, a pairing fans have long referred to as “Wolfstar.” The narrative eventually reaches its emotional conclusion around the time of Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, with threads of betrayal, loss, and hard-won redemption woven throughout.

The title is drawn from the classic Mott the Hoople song of the same name, and the story has taken on a life well beyond the page. On TikTok, the hashtag #ATYD has accumulated over 1.5 billion views, with fans routinely creating memes and casting their dream versions of the characters.

Andrew Garfield and Ben Barnes have become near-universal fan choices for Remus Lupin and Sirius Black respectively. Within LGBTQ+ fan communities in particular, the story has resonated deeply, offering the kind of representation that mainstream fantasy franchises have historically been slow to provide.

The reported auction has inevitably drawn comparisons to one of publishing’s most remarkable modern origin stories. Fifty Shades of Grey, which began life as Twilight fan fiction before being reworked into an independent novel, went on to earn approximately $569 million worldwide against a $40 million production budget. Its two sequels, Fifty Shades Darker and Fifty Shades Freed, pushed the trilogy’s global total past $1.3 billion.

The Twilight franchise that first inspired it was no small phenomenon either: the first film alone brought in roughly $407 million worldwide, and the five-film saga generated more than $3.3 billion globally.

When Fifty Shades first became a cultural phenomenon, J.K. Rowling, the creator of the Harry Potter universe, was asked repeatedly for her reaction. She kept her distance from the novel with characteristic dry humor.

Asked whether she had read it, she replied: “I promised my editor I wouldn’t.” When pressed on whether she felt she was missing out, her answer was equally brief: “Not wildly.” She did, however, offer one memorable tongue-in-cheek observation about the whole experience: “Just think how many books I could’ve sold if Harry had been a bit more creative with his wand.”

Now, with a story rooted in her own universe potentially fetching millions at auction, the literary chain that Rowling once joked about may be extending itself once again.